Since the infamous 2010 Citizens United ruling by the U.S.
Supreme Court, our elections have been inundated with gobs
of secret donations for spending by outside groups on
At the time, Justice Anthony Kennedy believed "prompt
disclosure" would be the rule. But Congress hasn't
So lawmakers in more than a dozen states, California among
them, are proposing legislation to force groups to disclose
their donors. They are right to jump in.
Californians have experienced firsthand the flood of secret
money. Remember the $11 million that the shadowy Americans
for Job Security helped funnel into California via Arizona
and Virginia in the last three weeks of the 2012 campaign?
The donors remain unknown.
The law needs to be changed.
A number of bills are making their way through the
Legislature that would amend the Political Reform Act of
Senate Bill 52, the California Disclose Act, would require
all television, radio, print and other ads for ballot
measures, independent expenditures and issue advocacy to
identify the three largest donors of $10,000 or more for
state races and $2,000 for local races.
SB 2 would establish a new "stand-by-your-ad" requirement
that lets voters know that a candidate "approves" an ad.
The bill also would require new quarterly statements of
contributions and campaign spending, instead of semi-
SB 27 would require political groups set up as tax-exempt
"social welfare" nonprofits to report a list of their top
10 contributors to the Fair Political Practices Commission
and the California secretary of state. In the Assembly, AB
914 would require these nonprofits to disclose the
identities of donors who give $10,000 or more.
Equally important to disclosure is having an electronic
filing system that can provide timely information on who is
financing campaigns. The secretary of state's 14-year old,
crash-prone Cal-Access system needs replacing. SB 3 would
require the secretary of state to complete a new electronic
filing system by December 2018. It should come sooner, but
legislators are concerned about tight budgets.
This package of bills should get out of each house with a
two-thirds vote by the end of this month. If there is no
easy way to stem the tide of unlimited money in elections,
voters and their elected leaders should insist upon greater